You are the owner of this article.
Judge in Elyse Erwin murder case denies reinstatement of stalking charge

Judge in Elyse Erwin murder case denies reinstatement of stalking charge

051217 jorge tovar arraignment

Jorge Tovar, 26, is accused of shooting and killing ex-girlfriend Elyse Erwin outside the 100 block of Goodwin Road on Easter Sunday morning. Authorities confirmed that Tovar and Erwin are parents to their six-year-old daughter. A criminal protective order has since been issued for the child following Tovar's arrest. Tovar remains in custody with no bail set.

A Santa Maria Superior Court judge has denied a deputy district attorney's motion to reinstate a stalking allegation against Jorge Tovar Fernandez, who is accused of shooting and killing his ex-girlfriend, Elyse Erwin, near an apartment complex near Waller Park in 2017.

Santa Barbara County Deputy District Attorney Anne Nudson asked the judge on Wednesday to reinstate a felony stalking charge against Fernandez, of Lompoc, arguing that there was sufficient evidence to prove the underlying offense at the preliminary hearing, even though no request was made at the time to hold the charge. 

At the preliminary hearing, it was the penalty enhancement of stalking after a restraining order that was discussed, but the charge wasn't held at the hearing. 

"It's not uncommon to prove different crimes as evidence comes out," Nudson said. 

After the hearing, prosecutors filed a separate case against Fernandez that included the stalking enhancement. 

In August, Judge John McGregor denied a request by the prosecution to combine the stalking case with Fernandez' murder case. 

The evidence presented at the preliminary hearing supported a regular felony stalking charge, Nudson said, but it was an "oversight" that the charge wasn't held. 

Jeremy Lessem, Fernandez' attorney, countered on Wednesday that the court doesn't have an obligation to reconsider a request that was never made, stating that the failure to make a request was a "fatal error" on the prosecution's part. 

"It's your obligation as the trier of fact in your hearing to say that I have a duty to look into this and see if there's something else that may be here besides what you charged in your one count complaint," Lessem said. 

A Santa Maria Superior Court judge continued the arraignment for murder suspect Jorge Tovar Fernandez, whose attorney asked for additional time to have her client dressed out to honor a media request to photograph in the courtroom. 

Nudson said even though the enhancement wasn't found at the preliminary hearing, the court should have considered the underlying offense since Fernandez allegedly had two contacts with Erwin after the restraining order was in effect. 

McGregor said that there has to be a legal error if no request was made on the regular felony stalking charge. 

"Doesn't that in essence put the court in the position of being the charging authority, something that would really be in the province of the district attorney's office rather than the court?" McGregor asked. "To me that seems to somewhat cross over the separation of powers." 

McGregor denied the request on that basis, stating that the failure to make the request involved no legal error.

Because the judge denied the request to add the regular stalking charge, the separate case is effectively over. 

The District Attorney's office filed to add the stalking to Fernandez' murder case, but it's considered a "wobbler," meaning that the judge has the power to reduce it to a misdemeanor for the purposes of sentencing. 

Fernandez is scheduled to reappear at 8:30 a.m. Jan. 24 in Department 8 of Santa Maria Superior Court. 


Sign up for our Crime & Courts newsletter

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Public Safety Reporter

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alert

Breaking News